How do I check a used car’s history before buying it?
Run a vehicle history report with the car’s 17-character VIN, then read the maintenance record as closely as the accident record. “What I look at is how often the vehicle visited a service center. Preferably, I want to see visits every 5,000 miles,” says Dane Babbitt, Used Vehicle Sales Director at Lexus of Southwest Houston.
A history report pulls together title records, reported accidents, odometer readings, and ownership changes for the VIN you enter. The record is only as complete as what was reported, so the way you read it matters as much as the report itself.
What should I look for in the service history?
Consistency. Many owners use the dealership for the first few visits while complimentary maintenance lasts, then service the car elsewhere. Where it happened matters less than whether it kept happening.
“What I am looking for is consistent visits every 5,000 miles or, if the customer does not drive that much, at least once a year.”
Dane Babbitt, Used Vehicle Sales Director at Lexus of Southwest Houston
Records from other shops can be thinner. “Third-party service records may not be as detailed,” Babbitt says. An entry that reads only “vehicle inspection” can still point to routine service. In his words: “You can infer some things from that.”
Why is maintenance missing from some reports?
It depends on how each repair order was written. Details listed as separate line items can carry over to the report, while a single oil-change line may show up as only an oil change. In Babbitt’s words, “it is mostly garbage in, garbage out.”
If the history looks thin, ask the seller for service receipts. For more, see how reliable a CARFAX report is.
What won’t a history report show?
Problems nobody reported, and problems you can only find by looking at the car. A clean report tells you nothing bad was reported, not that nothing bad happened. Here is what to look for in person, from Aaron Hogue:
“Flood damage may be indicated by musty odors, water stains under the carpet, corrosion on electrical connectors, mud in hard-to-reach areas, or rust in unusual locations.”
Aaron Hogue, Service Shop Foreman at Group 1 Ford of Southwest Houston
Signs of previous accident repairs include mismatched paint, uneven panel gaps, paint overspray, missing factory labels, or non-factory welds.
What else can I check before I buy?
An inspection adds what a report can’t. Hogue describes what a thorough one includes:
“A thorough pre-purchase inspection should include a complete mechanical inspection, a computer scan for fault codes, a road test, a brake and tire inspection, a check for leaks, and an evaluation of the vehicle’s accident and maintenance history.”
Aaron Hogue, Service Shop Foreman at Group 1 Ford of Southwest Houston
Two free checks are also worth a minute. The National Insurance Crime Bureau’s VINCheck flags cars reported stolen or declared a total loss by participating insurers. For a low-cost title check, the Federal Trade Commission points shoppers to vehiclehistory.gov, which lists approved providers of reports from the National Motor Vehicle Title Information System (NMVTIS).