What are OE tires, and are they better than aftermarket tires?

The Short Answer

OE (original equipment) tires are built to a specification the vehicle manufacturer developed with the tire manufacturer for that exact model, and they carry an OE code on the sidewall. An aftermarket tire with the same brand name and size but no code is a legitimate, safe tire, but it is not the same tire. “The vehicle manufacturer works with the tire manufacturer to get the exact spec. That’s the OE tire, and it’s built differently than what you can get in the aftermarket,” says Tom Heizer, Head of Aftersales Marketing and Digital Experience at Group 1 Automotive.

What makes an OE tire different?

When a new model is developed, the automaker and a tire maker tune a tire to that vehicle’s weight, suspension, noise targets, and handling goals. The result is sold with a manufacturer code molded into the sidewall: Mercedes-Benz’s “MO,” Audi’s “AO,” Porsche’s “N0,” Tesla’s “T0,” BMW’s star symbol, and similar marks from other brands. Michelin describes these as tires that went through a joint development and validation process with the automaker, sometimes with a unique compound, internal construction, or acoustic foam not present in the standard version of the same tire, and recommends replacing an OE-marked tire with one carrying the same marking. The differences are usually in construction rather than appearance. “It tends to be the sidewall, the amount of rubber in the tire, how it’s reinforced,” Heizer says. “It’s the same size and it’s round, but it’s engineered for that car, not something that kind of fits.”

A retail version of the same tire model, without the code, is built to the tire maker’s general spec for that size. It will fit and it will be safe. It may ride, wear, or handle a little differently than the tire the car was tuned around.

Will I actually notice the difference?

Be honest with yourself here, and Heizer is: “For the average driver, you’re probably not going to notice. It’s not apples and oranges. It’s a difference in how sturdy the tire is and how it was engineered.”

His analogy is running shoes. “One shoe fits perfectly and costs $150. Another is half the price and doesn’t fit quite as well, but it’s cheaper. Do you really want to run a marathon in the shoe that’s okay? It’s the only thing touching the ground.” Drivers who push their cars, carry family, or simply liked how the vehicle drove new have the clearest case for staying with OE. Drivers who want a quiet commuter tire at a lower price have a fair case for a quality aftermarket tire in the right category.

Is tire quality the same no matter where I buy?

For the same brand, model, size, and OE code, yes: it is the same physical product whether a dealership or an aftermarket store sells it. Where quality actually varies is between tires, not between retailers. Consumer Reports, which tested 129 tire models across 18 brands, found that price alone isn’t a reliable indicator of tire quality. Each tire also carries a UTQG rating (treadwear, traction, and temperature grades set under federal guidelines), which NHTSA established to help shoppers compare tires. Manufacturers run the tests themselves, so the grades are most useful for comparing tires within one brand rather than across brands.

Where the retailer does matter is selection. Dealerships generally stock the OE tire and the better tiers; aftermarket retailers carry the full spectrum, including budget tires a dealership won’t put on your car. “Budget tires usually wear quicker and don’t last as long,” Heizer says.

Do my replacement tires have to match the factory specs exactly?

No, but they can never fall below them. The load index and speed rating (the number and letter after the tire size on the sidewall) tell you how much weight the tire can carry and how fast it is rated to go. Michelin recommends never going below the original load index or speed rating, even when a lower-rated tire is cheaper.

“You don’t have to match the factory tire exactly. If you lift a truck or lower a sports car, you can change the size to suit what you’re doing,” Heizer says. “What you can never do is go less than what the vehicle was engineered for. Take a car whose tires are rated for 180 miles an hour. Put a tire rated for 110 mph on it, and it makes the vehicle unsafe. The same logic applies to load: a pickup or three-row SUV on a tire with a lower load index is carrying weight the tire wasn’t built to hold.”

How do I know which tire my car came with?

Look at the sidewall of your current tires for a manufacturer code near the model name. The door-jamb placard and owner’s manual list the size, load index, and speed rating. If the original tires have already been replaced, a dealership parts or service department can look up the OE tire for your exact VIN.

Ask a Group 1 Automotive service advisor about OE tires for your vehicle

Group 1 Automotive 29.77820259298989, -95.55981488530338.