How much can you realistically negotiate off a new car’s sticker price?
Most buyers pay a few percent under sticker, and how much room there is depends on how long that specific vehicle has been in stock. “Pricing comes down to supply and demand. A vehicle with a one- or two-day supply won’t have the same discounts as one that has been sitting in inventory for 60 days,” says Matt Baugher, General Manager at Group 1 Kia Hub City.
Kelley Blue Book reports that in August 2026 the average new car sold for $50,089 against an average sticker price of $51,852. That is about $1,760, or roughly 3.4%, below MSRP.
How much are other buyers actually paying below sticker?
On average, not much. Automaker incentives, such as cash rebates and discounted financing, averaged 6.5% of the transaction price in August 2026, down from 7.2% a year earlier, according to Kelley Blue Book. Edmunds found discounts of around 4% off MSRP in early 2025, while before the pandemic, December discounts averaged more than 7%.
Averages hide a wide range. Consumer Reports recently found some luxury models selling for 6% to 10% below sticker, while popular models in short supply may not move at all. See which new cars have the most room to negotiate.
Should I focus on the monthly payment or the total price?
The total. The monthly payment is one number; what the car costs over time is the whole picture.
“Buyers often focus on the monthly payment and overlook the total cost of ownership. Fuel, maintenance, and insurance can make a more expensive vehicle cost considerably more over time.”
Matt Baugher, General Manager at Group 1 Kia Hub City
The Federal Trade Commission also warns that a lower monthly payment often means a longer loan term and more interest, which can substantially raise your total cost. For a rebate-versus-rate comparison, see how to choose between a manufacturer rebate and low-rate financing.